Quotes from the Legal Press

Who's Who Legal Germany: Patents 2017

Four practitioners are highlighted at the highly regarded boutique Bardehle Pagenberg Partnerschaft. Jochen Pagenberg is one of the most instantly recognisable names in German IP law. He is widely praised for his longstanding and eminent practice. Johannes Heselberger impresses clients with his “wide-ranging knowledge” and “ability to think quickly on his feet”. He is considered an “outstanding choice” for infringement proceedings in the medical devices, telecoms and automotive industries. Tilman Müller-Stoy and Christof Karl are also recognised in our research for their outstanding contribution to patents law in Germany.

Even more Tilman Müller-Stoy and Jochen Pagenberg are two of only seven "Most Highly Regarded Individuals" of Who's Who Legal "with a proven track record of their work advising and representing clients in relation to their patent portfolios and patent litigation needs".

WIPR Leaders 2016

"Bardehle Pagenberg trumps the competition in Germany with eight leaders, and second spot is shared between four firms with five leaders each: Bird & Bird; Freshfields Bruckhaus Deringer; Hogan Lovells; and Hoyng Rokh Monegier."

Patents & Trademarks

Chambers Global Germany and Chambers Global Europe, 2016

Robust IP boutique, well recognised in patent litigation, prosecution and trade marks. Represents several of its corporate clients in all instances domestically as well as internationally. Offers a prosecution team with a focus on highly technical filings and patent proceedings relating to nanotechnology, biotechnology and semiconductor physics. Advises several well-known brands on their trade mark portfolios and design laws.

Strengths (Quotes mainly from clients):

"It is like a role model to other firms. The lawyers are analytical and detailed, they really think through their advice. They are impressive on the litigation side in how they prepare and litigate cases."

"It is a strong and sharp team."

Work Highlights: Advised adidas on several nullity proceedings against Nike regarding the adizero Primeknit shoes. Advises Dell on all its European patent application filings, including representation in invalidity and infringement proceedings.

Notable practitioners: 

Now of counsel, Udo Altenburg remains an important figure in the firm and has vast experience of patent prosecution, particularly in the field of medical devices.

Described by clients as a "brilliant attorney," of counsel Jochen Pagenberg is best known for co-ordinating the firm's resources in multi-jurisdictional mandates and parallel proceedings.

Johannes Heselberger is well respected for patent infringement and validity actions in the biotechnology, telecoms and automotive industries. Clients value that "he comes across as very convincing in negotiations."

Patent litigator Tilman Müller-Stoy is frequently seen representing clients in high-profile cross-border proceedings, often in the sectors of telecoms, IT and medical devices. He represented Microsoft in several patent infringements and nullity actions, most notably related to Android. Clients say: "He is a great presenter in court hearings. He is calm and has a strong fact base."

Hans Wegner is a trusted patent adviser to some of the firm's key clients. He handles all matters relating to patents, utility models and design, particularly concerning mechanics, physics and sports equipment. He regularly advises Qualcomm on European patent applications. A client remarks: "He has a long-term view and strategy that is highly appreciated."

Head of trade marks Claus Eckhartt is best known for trade mark prosecution, as well as advising on design and copyright infringements. Clients describe him as "commercial, easy to work with and pragmatic." He represented Thermo Fisher Scientific in a dispute with a competitor regarding a misleading statement about one of its products.

Managing partner Peter Hess specialises in patent infringements, most notably in the telecoms, technology and optoelectronic industries. One client states: "He is very responsive and looks at things from a very strategic perspective. He understands our business."

Johannes Lang is a qualified French patent attorney and regularly works on French cross-border and parallel litigation. He is best known for patent prosecutions for software, electronics and IT companies. One client states: "He gave quick advice and was very easy to work with."

Christof Karl frequently represents Japanese clients in patent litigation and prosecution. Interviewees state: "His advice is clear and convincing. He has good experience with Japanese companies and his team is strong and sharp."

Giovanni Casucci is described as an "excellent lawyer when it comes to counterfeiting issues" and is praised for having "very broad knowledge of different jurisdictions."

The Legal 500 Germany 2017

Bardehle Pagenberg gives ‘smart, strategic advice’ and displays ‘fighting spirit in court’. Claus Eckhartt, Henning Hartwig and Alexander von Mühlendahl are particularly recommended. Eckhartt is the trusted trade mark adviser for Coca-Cola, including prosecution, litigation and border seizures; he also regularly acts for GlaxoSmithKline. Hartwig successfully represented watchmaker Neuhaus in design litigation against its competitor, MeisterSinger. SIGG, Australian Gold and Industex are also clients of the practice.

Bardehle Pagenberg’s ‘excellent’ team provides ‘honest and pragmatic risk assessment, taking into account all legal, technical and commercial aspects’. Mechanical and electrical engineering are key sectors of expertise, alongside IT. The practice defended Bosch in several patent infringement proceedings and successfully defended Cisco Systems in an IT systems dispute. ‘Brilliant strategist’ Tilman Müller-Stoy ‘keeps his cool, even when it gets emotional in court, and presents complex subject matter in an outstanding manner’. Johannes Heselberger heads the practice.

Bardehle Pagenberg is a ‘prime example of a perfect cooperation between firm and client’. The team brings to bear its ‘comprehensive sector knowledge’ when advising clients on the gamut of technical areas, with a focus on IT and mechanical and electrical engineering. Key clients include Apple Inc, Qualcomm, Adidas and Nintendo. Hans Wegner has ‘incredible intuition for details and strategy’; Martin Hohgardt ‘understands clients’ needs’; Christian Haupt is able to ‘skilfully present technical issues before authorities’; and Johannes Lang gives ‘clear advice’.

Best Lawyers 2015 and 2016

BARDEHLE PAGENBERG has been – again – named "Law Firm of the Year" for Intellectual Property Law and is “Top-Listed” by Best Lawyers® and Handelsblatt.

The following members of the firm are currently recommended in “Best Lawyers” for their Intellectual Property practice, on the basis of an extensive peer review, with BARDEHLE PAGENBERG being among the few firms with 11 firm members listed in this field of law.

Johannes Heselberger, Claus M. Eckhartt, Christof Karl, Tilman Müller-Stoy, Peter K. Hess, Johannes LangHans Wegner, Jochen Pagenberg,
Wolfgang Bublak, Peter J.A. Munzinger, Udo W. Altenburg

Chambers Global Germany and Chambers Global Europe, 2015

What the team is known for: "Best known for its outstanding patent litigation practice, with additional strength in patent prosecution, where it is regularly active in application and opposition proceedings before the European Patent Office and Federal Patent Court. Offers additional capabilities in complex unfair competition matters."
 
Strengths (Quotes mainly from clients): "The best in Germany, from my point of view.", "Bardehle Pagenberg has an excellent reputation and can represent you comprehensively with regard to all areas of IP law."
 
Work highlights: "Represented adidas in a case concerning its patent for a technology relating to the manufacture of balls for use in sport. Acted for Dell on its prosecution of a number of patents before the German Patent and Trade Mark Office and European Patent Office. Advised SIGG on a claim against NICI alleging the imitation of SIGG's water bottle closure design."

Notable practitioners: "Sources recognise founding partner Jochen Pagenberg as a “big name" in patent litigation and appreciate his long-standing experience in the German market. Interviewees identify department head Johannes Heselberger as an "experienced" patent litigator. His recent highlights include advising Vestel Germany on patent infringement and nullity proceedings against Thomson Licensing. Clients describe Tilman Müller-Stoy as a "fabulous patent litigator," adding: "He's really great. He gets into the technology and argues our case outstandingly in court." His recent mandates include advising new client Pronomic on patent infringement proceedings. Clients say Hans Wegner is "very much into the details and a great strategic thinker - excellent value for money." He recently advised adidas on its prosecution of all European patents and designs. Udo Altenburg is best known for his patent prosecution work, where he has domestic and multinational clients before patent authorities. Claus Eckhartt has handled a number of contentious matters relating to trade marks of late. Clients praise his performance, saying: "His opinions are detailed and clear for us to understand." Peter Hess is recognised for his patent prosecution work and of late has been particularly active in the electronics and technology sectors. Managing partner Johannes Lang represents clients from the consumer electronics and IT in patent opposition, appeal and invalidation proceedings. He is also a qualified French patent attorney, with extensive experience of French patent litigation procedure and discovery proceedings."

The Legal 500 EMEA 2015

Patent Litigation:
"Johannes Heselberger heads Bardehle Pagenberg’s team, which clients value because ‘not only are legal implications taken into account, but also the commercial impact of litigation’. Highlights included successfully defending one of Adidas’ patents for sports ball manufacturing and representing key client Cisco in network technology infringement and nullity proceedings. Tilman Müller-Stoy ‘never loses control, never forgets an argument and knows when to raise his voice’. Jörg Wahl has ‘great attention to detail and an impressive ability to hit the ground running’."

Patent Prosecution:
"Bardehle Pagenberg’s ‘quality of advice sets the benchmark’. The team covers all areas but key strengths remain IT and mechanical engineering, with pharmaceuticals being a growing area for the team, which has ‘comprehensive sector knowledge’. Hans Wegner has ‘a remarkable sense of details and strategy’, Martin Hohgardt ‘knows what clients need’ and Christian Haupt ‘knows how to present technically difficult matters in court’. Adidas, Dell and Qualcomm are longstanding clients."

Trademarks (including Competition):
"Bardehle Pagenberg gives ‘informed and clear advice’. Henning Hartwig has particular expertise in litigation and registered design law, while Claus Eckhartt, who ‘grasps the client’s situation with minimal communication needed’, focuses on trade mark registration for McDonald’s and Coca-Cola, among others. Mondelēz receives community trade mark litigation advice and SIGG has been successfully represented in competition litigation regarding bottle closure imitations. Alexander von Mühlendahl is ‘a legal heavyweight’."

Who's Who Legal - Germany 2015

Once again have been selected by Who's Who Legal research with clients and peers as being amongst the world's leading patent lawyers:
Johannes Heselberger, Tilman Müller-Stoy, Julien Fréneaux, Giovanni Francesco CasucciJochen Pagenberg


Once again have been selected by Who's Who Legal research with clients and peers as being amongst the world's leading trademark lawyers:
Claus Eckhartt, Henning HartwigAlexander von Mühlendahl, Jochen Pagenberg, Peter Munzinger

IAM Patent 1000 – 2015

Germany
"“Timely and accurate”, the “high-quality” output of BARDEHLE PAGENBERG makes it “a role model for firms around the world”. Promoted to gold this year, the team has successfully cross-pollinated its practices, receiving contentious instructions from satisfied prosecution clients including adidas, Dell and Cisco. The “outstanding and accomplished” Johannes Heselberger is the set’s star litigator. He shines in oppositions, appeals and infringement proceedings in the country’s highest courts. “Supremely persuasive”, Tilman Müller-Stoy “has a great way of presenting arguments. He is fantastically confident; his ability to quickly grasp the technical details of a case has often been the decisive factor. Working with him is an absolute pleasure”. On the non-contentious side, Hans Wegner “has great strategic sense. He is an enormously precious asset; the way a hearing is prepared by Hans and his team is second to none. They consider all the options and have back-up plans for all scenarios”. A veteran of complex cross-border litigation, Johannes Lang bolsters the firm’s offering. Qualified as a French patent attorney, he brings an extra dimension to international matters. Peter Hess wins plaudits for his impressive representation of a leading electronics company in opposition proceedings at the European Patent Office (EPO), while luminary Jochen Pagenberg lends inimitable gravitas to the team."

Italy
"Revered German outfit BARDEHLE PAGENBERG made waves when it joined forces with Studio Legale Casucci Ferretti, melding impressive pan-European capabilities with deep insight into the Italian legal system and market. The combination appears to have worked out well, as there is no shortage of demand for its services. Giovanni Francesco Casucci remains the key figure here; peers admire the diligence of this “very well-prepared professional” both in and out of court. The consummate litigator can also draw on considerable transactional nous to advise on technology transfer matters."

France
"Dexterously managing complex parallel litigation proceedings in line with an overriding international strategy is BARDEHLE PAGENBERG’s Julien Fréneaux. A veteran of infringement and nullity proceedings, he is a vital asset for those with concerns in medical devices, sports equipment and mechanical engineering."

WTR 1000 The World’s Leading Trademark Professionals 2015

Germany
"Steadfast boutique BARDEHLE PAGENBERG provides the full range of trademark services, from portfolio management to litigation before the European Court of Justice (ECJ). Thanks to the firm’s prowess in designs, it routinely secures difficult-to-obtain shape marks for clients. Anti-counterfeiting is another forte; the firm is well versed in customs procedures for monitoring imports and exports. Henning Hartwig “is a consummate expert in design rights and brings the full force of this knowledge to bear on trademark issues”. Head of the firm’s trademark department Claus Eckhartt represents market leaders in a diverse range of industries and was recently involved in a precedent-setting case involving bottle shapes. Trademark doyen Alexander von Mühlendahl has a remarkable CV: he was the vice president of OHIM for 11 years and has served as head of trademarks and unfair competition law at the Ministry of Justice."

Italy
"The “much-reputed” Giovanni Casucci at Bardehle Pagenberg Studio Legale Casucci Ferretti “stands out among all others as a top lawyer with a strategic vision in litigation and transactions. He immediately understands the business and economic drivers behind a company”."

France
"Rebecca Delorey boasts a “deep understanding of clients’ needs. We consider her a true partner and would rely on her for the most complicated trademark issues”."

Managing IP - IP Stars 2015

Patent
"A client says the firm has "a strong expertise in patent prosecution, both before the EPO and the USPTO". He adds: "They effectively obtained strong legal protection of key inventions that serve us to stand out from competitors. Furthermore, their great knowledge in several technical fields suits our needs as we have a diverse patent portfolio. Their expertise in infringement and validity analysis, as well as in licensing negotiations, is a tremendous asset for our company."

The team has been assisting Adidas against Nike on the defence of a basic patent for the production of sport balls, used for the 2014 FIFA World Cup. It has also represented Cisco in patent infringement and patent invalidity proceedings against Kangtega, in a matter related to network engineering. This year, partner Peter Hess garners praise for being a "greatly experienced professional with a deep interest in licensing". Another client adds: "His support in licensing negotiations with third parties has been key to reach reasonable agreements for both parties.""

Trade Mark & Copyright
"Maintaining its high reputation, Bardehle Pagenberg works from its offices in Munich, Düsseldorf, Milan, Paris and Barcelona. Dealing both with prosecution and litigation, the firm has a team of around 60 professionals, including former judges and former vice-president of the OHIM Alexander Von Mühlendahl.

This past year it has represented Swiss bottle manufacturer Sigg in a dispute related to aluminium bottle closures. The defendant was manufacturing the copies of the product and the courts found it was a product imitation ("misappropriation") that would deceive consumers as to the origin of the product. Partner Henning Hartwig led the team in litigation for client H&M. They managed to enforce its rights regarding the design of a shape of a cosmetic container. Other clients include Australian Gold, Nike and Nintendo."

Chambers Global 2014

Johannes Heselberger heads the patent litigation group and recently represented Vestel Group in a dispute with Thomson Licensing.

Market observers view of counsel Jochen Pagenberg as an experienced and highly knowledgeable practitioner. He focuses on patent enforcement in the fields of software, pharmaceuticals and biotechnology.

Udo Altenburg is noted for his advice on patent prosecutions. He has a focus on medical devices and mechanical engineering.

Tilman Müller-Stoy is described as “highly respected and full of good ideas.” He successfully defended adidas against Nike in recent preliminary injunction proceedings.

Patent attorney Hans Wegner is a frequent adviser on patent application proceedings before the German and European patent offices.

Peter Hess was part of the team advising Microsoft on obtaining a patent injunction against Motorola. He focuses on patent infringement.

Managing partner Johannes Lang advises on patent invalidation proceedings before the German Federal Court of Justice and the German Federal Patent Court in Munich. He is also French-qualified and co-ordinates customer seizures and patent cases with the firm’s Paris office.

The Legal 500 EMEA 2014

Patent Litigation:

‘A role model in terms of quality’, Bardehle Pagenberg’s broad practice is ‘an incredible presence’ for its clients and ‘combines passion and high performance’.

Patent Prosecution:

Bardehle Pagenberg represents ‘good value for money’ because ‘the quality is excellent’.

Trademarks (including Competition):

Bardehle Pagenberg is recommended for its ‘analytical skills’ and ‘precise statements’.

IAM Patent 1000 – 2014

With an A-to-Z patent offering, BARDEHLE PAGENBERG is the epitome of sophistication: “Even its rivals can’t deny that it is wildly successful.” One peer confides: “Of all the firms in Germany, it is the only one which I would consider a competitor. It has a huge reputation which it justifies year after year.” Litigation group head Johannes Heselberger “is the best of the best – he has a wealth of experience and his marriage of technical and legal skills is seamless”. Drawing “endorsements from across the world”, Tilman Müller-Stoy “is probably the best young lawyer in the patent field”. Elder statesman Jochen Pagenberg has made a significant contribution to the firm’s success, while the versatile Hans Wegner deftly handles a myriad of patent concerns. Johannes Lang “can navigate the trickiest briefs with finesse”. Rounding out the team, Peter K Hess “maintains his high standing”.

WTR 1000 The World’s Leading Trademark Professionals 2014

IP titan Bardehle Pagenberg has enjoyed a standout year: in May 2013 it secured victory on behalf of Kraft Foods in a headline-grabbing Supreme Court case. A media mainstay, it frequently appears in big-ticket enforcement actions for noteworthy clients. The sheer extent of its team allows it to excel in high-volume prosecution briefs. Esteemed Alexander von Mühlendahl was vice president of the Office for Harmonisation in the Internal Market (OHIM) for 11 years, giving him a first-hand insight on noncontentious matters. Breaking into the tables for the first time this year, trademark department head Claus M Eckhartt has enjoyed the patronage of a world leader in the beverage industry for the past decade. “Exceptional litigator” Henning Hartwig “should be highlighted. He is a terrific lawyer and a true design expert who really cares about developments in this area of law”. Peter JA Munzinger “is a renowned lawyer who has been a stalwart of the marketplace”.

JUVE German Commercial Law Firms 2013/2014

Patent Law:

A leading firm in patents which is well prepared for the changes ahead due to the new EU patent/UPC. BP is one of the standout litigation firms in Germany with patent attorneys and lawyers, as evidenced for years by its strong visibility in mobile communications and software suits. […] As a boutique, BP is more internationally positioned than most competitors and already has lawyers at the future UPC seat in Paris. The firm also internalizes the mixed approach of patent attorneys and lawyers more intensively than most German patent firms. This way of conducting patents work will be important in the new European system, according to general opinion. In addition, BP has an “exceptional reputation among US companies” according to a competitor […]. So as not to be too dependent on US companies, BP is stepping up filing activity for Asian companies. The firm already operates a strong European filing practice.

Trademarks & Design Law / Unfair Competition Law:

This highly recommended firm in trademarks and unfair competition maintained its visibility. Again it was BP’s expertise in design law, esp. supporting the patents practice, that drew attention. The market closely followed the merger with Italian IP boutique Casucci-Ferretti, with whom BP had already worked in the past. The firm thus raised its international visibility and established contacts among Italian consumer goods manufacturers.

Recommended in:

Press Contact:

For press inquiries or interviews with partners of the firm, we are at your disposal:

Gabriela Tröger
Marketing & PR
T +49.(0)89.928 05-0
gabriela.troeger@bardehle.de